Dr. Stephen Heffernan, Batch Chemistry Technical Applications Specialist, Syrris
Going beyond the round-bottom flask: how to automate your chemistry
Speaking from experience, chemists tend to be creatures of habit – myself included – requiring a relatively high level of activation energy to make changes to methodology and/or technology. This is highlighted by the fact that synthetic methods and tools have remained largely unchanged over the last 200 years, meaning nearly every chemistry lab in the world has an extensive collection of round-bottom flasks.
The problems with traditional chemistry and round-bottom flasks – and their solutions
This reliance on traditional methods has placed restrictions on synthetic chemistry; limited temperature ranges, lack of repeatability, and the need for constant experiment supervision. These difficulties fly in the face of the ever-growing pressure on synthetic organic chemists to develop innovative chemical reactions and compounds quickly and efficiently.
This post aims to introduce how modern laboratory technology – such as jacketed reactors and software automation – can enable you to perform more reliable, consistent, and reproducible chemistry, even when you’re away from the lab bench or fume hood.
If you already know how automated chemistry systems work, check out our “5 benefits of automated lab chemistry systems” blog post
The challenge: Difficulty in accurately maintaining reaction temperatures
During my Ph.D. I worked almost exclusively at 4 temperatures: reflux, room temperature, 0 °C, and -78 °C. This limited temperature range was selected purely for the relative ease of maintaining reactions at each of these temperatures, something I’m sure many chemists can identify with.
- Reflux – just heat until your reaction boils
- Room temperature, although variable, speaks for itself
- 0 °C can be achieved with an ice bath
- -78 °C is the result of a mixture of acetone and dry ice
Accurately controlling these temperatures is still tricky, despite being “relatively easy” to maintain. I once, foolishly, attempted to carry out a 4-hour reaction at -40 °C, which involved adding dry ice to an acetone bath piece by piece until I reached the desired temperature. Needless to say, my temperature control was less than ideal, as each piece of dry ice added to the bath would cause the temperature to drop by a few degrees before slowly returning to -40 °C.
In reality, chemistry can be carried out across a far wider spectrum of temperatures, offering the possibility of better selectivity, improved yield, or the avoidance of unwanted side-products; but it’s hard to achieve and/or maintain temperatures other than the “big 4” mentioned above with traditional lab glassware.
The solution: Pinpoint accuracy in temperature control with jacketed reactor vessels and circulators
Advancements in laboratory glassware have led to the creation and widespread use of the jacketed reactor – double-walled glass vessels that allow for a “jacket” of oil to surround the reaction. This oil is constantly circulated by an external circulator and provides pinpoint accuracy in temperature control down to fractions of degrees. Not only does this enable much more consistent reaction temperatures, but it also provides easy temperature “ramping” – something that’s virtually impossible with round-bottom flasks.
Jacketed reactors are available in a huge range of sizes, from as low as 50 mL through to 50 L (or more), depending on your chemistry and scale.
The challenge: The need for constant reaction supervision
The second challenge facing chemists is freeing themselves from having to constantly interact with and monitor their reactions. My story above is just one example of when I had to stand in front of a lab bench, slowly feeding dry ice into my round-bottom flasks for 4 hours.
Constantly supervising your reactions is time-consuming, and, frankly, boring. I love performing chemistry, but it’s hard to deny that some parts of it are frustrating. It prevents you from performing other chemistry at the same time or can get in the way of taking the time to expand your knowledge by reading interesting papers.
The solution: Software automation and monitoring
Jacketed reactors, when combined with software automation, enable truly automated, walk-away chemical synthesis and have revolutionized the chemistry lab.
Automated jacketed reactors and automation add-ons for manual jacketed reactors use intelligent software that can control and constantly monitor your reaction through a number of probes (temperature, stirring speed, pH, turbidity, etc.). Working in conjunction with a circulator and temperature probe, the software can automatically compensate for any temperature fluctuations (exotherms/endotherms) by heating or cooling the oil flowing through the jacket. Combined with intelligent pumps you can also set up automated temperature-dependent and pH controlled dosing into your reaction.
Taking the intelligent automation further, you can set up entire complex recipes for your chemistry. Set-up your complete reaction prep, including all temperature set-points and reagent dosing and then walk away, allowing reactions to run autonomously, even when you have gone home for the evening/weekend! Smart safety features monitor your reaction and can shut it down in the event of reaching user-defined limits.
The ability to set and forget your chemistry frees up your time to analyze data from previous experiments, design your next reaction, or catch up on interesting publications you’ve been eager to read.
The challenge: Issues with reaction repeatability and reproducibility of results
Nearly all chemists will at some point have scratched their head when two apparently identical experiments produce significantly different results. This is all the more frustrating when you’ve had to supervise a reaction for hours on end.
A perfect example of this comes from my time supervising an undergraduate student during his final year research project. We were carrying out a rearrangement reaction using a weak base and had to keep the temperature at -90 °C to avoid unwanted side-products. No matter what we did, his reactions would not provide the desired product while mine would. As much as I would like to think it came down to my superior laboratory technique, even when we did the experiments side-by-side, we still had significant differences in success.
The solution: Software automation and data logging
Automation software automatically collects and logs all data from your reaction in real time. No reaction events escape detection, allowing your reactions to be compared side-by-side. This enables you to identify any differences in reaction conditions between experiments – particularly useful when things haven’t gone quite to plan! When combined with a preconfigured recipe, researchers can be confident that their experimental conditions will be the same every time – it’s just a matter of pressing “Start” and letting the system perform the reaction with no room for human error.
Top 5 benefits of automated jacketed reactor systems
We’ve put a whole blog post together covering the top 5 benefits of automated chemistry systems, but you can see the short version in the infographic below.
But wait! What about continuous flow chemistry?
I’d be remiss if I failed to mention continuous flow chemistry techniques when talking about “modern chemistry technology” and improving upon traditional chemistry. Continuous flow is a radically different approach to performing chemistry and involves pumping reagents through tubes or pipes – but it is far too big a subject to cover in this blog post. See all the blog posts covering the ins and outs of flow chemistry.
Enjoy chemistry automation in your lab
Whether you’re working with round-bottomed flasks and are looking to step into the world of jacketed reactors, or you’re already using one, speak to Syrris today to find out how you can enjoy the benefits of lab automation.
About Dr. Stephen Heffernan
As a Batch Chemistry Applications Specialist for Syrris, Stephen is responsible for many technical pre-sales inquiries, producing applications notes, and performing feasibility studies for potential customers. Stephen is also the Product Manager for the Atlas HD family of automated chemical reactors at Syrris. Read Stephen’s bio here.
Let’s start with the basics and explain what flow chemistry actually is and talk a bit about why it’s so useful. Flow chemistry is the process of performing chemical reactions in a tube or pipe. Read on to learn more…read more
So why should your lab consider performing your chemistry using continuous flow chemistry techniques? Discover several reasons including faster and reactions, and accessing novel chemistries not possible in batchread more
My first introduction to practical flow chemistry was as a Research Chemist at Pfizer and my first thought was: “why on earth would I want to conduct my chemistry in tiny tubes?” A few years later I was the biggest advocate for it. This blog post explains why…read more
What is catalysis? What is a catalyst? How does catalysis work? And why would you want to perform catalysis in continuous flow? Flow Chemistry Applications Specialist, Neal, explains why chemists like to incorporate catalysts into their chemistry and the benefits they bring…read more
Sometimes the biggest hurdle for chemists adopting flow chemistry is the time it takes to convert a batch process into a seamless flow set-up – but it doesn’t have to be! This post covers the 7 main things you should consider when implementing continuous flowread more
With modern technology, you can automate your entire lab if you wanted to, from automated liquid handling and motorized pipettes through to robots labeling your samples. But the easiest place to start is the source of your reactions – your jacketed reactor.read more