Neal Munyebvu, Technical Support Specialist, Syrris
7 things to keep in mind when adopting flow chemistry
Sometimes the biggest hurdle for chemists adopting flow chemistry is the time it takes to convert a batch process into a seamless flow set-up – but it doesn’t have to be!
Whether you want gradual or immediate adoption, this post covers the 7 main things you should consider when you are looking to convert your batch process into continuous flow.
We know chemists are inquisitive creatures and love to discover things for themselves, but we’ve been helping chemists implement flow chemistry since 2001. We’d love to discuss your applications and whether they’re possible in continuous flow; don’t hesitate to contact us to chat to an expert!
1. What is your application and is it suitable for continuous flow?
There’s a library of publications from chemists using continuous flow techniques to perform a wide range of different chemical reactions. If it can be done using traditional chemistry, it can often also be achieved using flow chemistry.
While many chemists are performing their entire process in continuous flow, It’s worth bearing in mind that some reactions may benefit from a combination of continuous flow chemistry techniques and traditional batch techniques. This combined approach may offer the best of both worlds, enabling you to perform specific portions of a reaction pathway in flow, rather than the entire process. Synthesis to and from intermediates to be used in batch processes downstream for example is common.
Some applications that may seem inaccessible can reliably be performed in continuous flow, such as;
Reactions reliant on heterogenous solid-liquid phase chemistry
Using solids may not seem immediately intuitive as part of ‘flow’ chemistry, however, a lot of work has been done using packed bed columns and flowing reagents over a packed bed solid catalyst/substrate. It’s worth noting that many chemists are able to remove the need for solids in their chemistry due to the benefits flow chemistry when they adapt it to continuous flow
Reactions using extremely sensitive or dangerous reagents
Compared to the traditional methods of dosing dangerous reagents into the entire contents of a round-bottomed flask or jacketed reactor, the nature of flow chemistry – reacting small quantities continuously – means hazardous reagents and intermediates are much more accessible using small volume reactors which limit risk.
Just the mention of an incredibly explosive reagent such as diazomethane is enough to grab the rapt attention of most chemists – but continuous flow makes it incredibly safe as you create tiny quantities of it continuously as demonstrated by Oliver Kappe and his team at the University of Graz – access the fascinating paper here. (If you’re unaware of just how much diazomethane makes chemists quiver, read this blog post!).
2. What would you like to achieve using continuous flow chemistry?
Are you looking to synthesize product(s) anywhere from small scale to pilot to manufacturing scale quantities? All possible in continuous flow.
Imagine flow chemistry as a tap; turn it on and you can fill a cup, but leave it running and you can fill a bath. Of course, the equipment required as you step-up or down each scale will vary – for example, manufacturing-scale synthesis will require pumps that can handle very high flow rates to achieve more product in smaller amounts of time – but the principle remains the same.
A common misconception is that continuous flow chemistry is inherently slower than performing a batch reaction because the quantity of reagents reacting at any one time is small. In reality, the increased pressures and temperatures flow enables can significantly reduce the time required for each reaction, as well as enabling much faster reaction optimization (as explained below).
Batch chemistry reactions can be laborious to optimize, often requiring several vials/round-bottomed flasks/jacketed reactors, each with changes in the reaction conditions. In continuous flow, you use automated liquid handling modules, such as the Asia Automated Reagent Injector, along with automation software, to automatically run 10s-100s of reactions on one system.
Inline sample analysis
Would you like to analyze a sample immediately after it is produced to ensure you are creating the right product? Continuous flow systems offer the capability to perform inline sample collection, dilution, and injection directly into your preferred online analysis method.
Depending on your set-up you are not limited to just one. There are many application areas to explore around and within these areas including flow electrochemistry, photochemistry, or In-line workup.
3. Don’t reinvent the wheel: read relevant papers that are related to the chemistry you would like to perform
Thanks to the huge library of papers now available using flow chemistry across a wide range of applications, there’s a good chance that similar chemistry (whether it’s direct application, methodology, or both) has already been performed. Browse as much literature as you can, and use this wealth of information to help improve the initial idea and design of your experiment going forward.
4. Design your initial experiment
Flow chemistry pumps, pressure, the reactor(s), and some form of manual or automated collection, are the main components of a flow chemistry reactor system.
Each parameter of your chemistry that requires precise control is important in considering which components you will need to add to this and ultimately the final design; view the full list of the available flow chemistry components here.
The various reaction parameters (and the technology that enables them) are explained below;
Pumping and flow rates
What flow rates will you need to obtain the residence times your chemistry requires? The Asia Flow Chemistry Syringe Pump offers highly accurate flow rates from 1 μL to 10 mL/min, enabling both extremely long and extremely fast residence and times.
The design of the pump plays a role as well; syringe pumps provide significantly smoother flow at ultra-slow and fast flow rates and no cavitation compared to peristaltic pumps, for example.
What temperature extremes do you need to go to? Will one heating/cooling module be enough or will you need multiple for your various chemistries? Most commercial lab-scale flow chemistry systems offer various heating/cooling modules and the ability to heat/cool different types of reactors, depending on your needs. For the Syrris Asia Flow Chemistry System, chemists can choose from the following;
- The Asia Heater provides heating for all types of Asia reactors due to an interchangeable adapter. Glass microreactors can be heated to 250 ºC, tube reactors can be heated to 125 ºC (fluoropolymer) or 250 ºC (stainless steel), and solid phase column reactors can be heated to 150 ºC
- The Asia Chip Climate Controller enables a range of glass microreactors to be cooled or heated from -15 ºC to +150 ºC without the need for an external circulator or cold water supply
- The Asia Cryo Controller rapidly cools fluoropolymer or stainless steel tube reactors to -70 °C or glass or quartz microreactors to -100 °C
- The Asia Tube Cooler rapidly cools fluoropolymer or stainless steel tube reactors to -68 °C
Residence time (reaction time) and type of chemistry
How long does your chemistry need to fully react? Glass microreactors offer very high temperatures but relatively short residence times, whereas tube reactors offer much longer residence times but generally lower temperatures (unless stainless steel is used). Column reactors enable the use of solid phase catalysts in your chemistry if required.
Operating at pressure enables far higher solvent boiling points, enabling faster reactions and opening up novel chemistry spaces. What pressure(s) will your chemistry require? Will you be working with gases, and/or air and moisture sensitive reagents?
The Asia Pressure Controller enables you to pressurize the system up to 20 bar. The Pressurized Input Store enables the use of air and moisture sensitive reagents but also assists in delivering an extremely smooth flow by minimizing input cavitation and gas bubble formation during pumping at high flow rates
What kind of in-line work-up or analysis will you be performing? Many continuous flow chemistry systems enable the use of in-line work-up and analytics. For example, the Asia FLLEX (Flow Liquid-Liquid EXtraction) Separator Module is the flow chemistry equivalent of a separatory funnel. Operating continuously, this aqueous workup/extraction module initially mixes the organic product stream with an aqueous phase, then allows time for diffusion to occur before finally splitting the flow back to its constituent parts. It also enables you to separate two-phase mixtures that would be extremely difficult by typical techniques e.g. THF and an aqueous phase, thanks to the use of advanced membrane technology instead of gravity.
The Asia Sampler and Dilutor (SAD) Module enables on-line reaction analysis by offering automated sample extraction, dilution, and transfer to virtually any LCMS, GCMS, UPLC, etc. without stopping the experiment.
5. Perform your first experiments
Once you’ve decided which components you need for your chemistry, it’s time to build your system. Simply set-up each of your separate components and connect them using tubes, and then you’re ready to go.
Like all scientists know too well, it is unlikely you will achieve perfect results after your very first experiment. There are a few tips that can help to make your initial experiments smoother and avoid early frustration:
Prime your flow system and ensure you avoid leaks!
Leaks result in losing solvents or worse, precious reagents, lowering the pressure of your system and introducing air/contaminants. Any of these are detrimental to the smooth running of any flow system.
Run initial experiments at low concentrations
The effectiveness of reactions can be surprising for first-time continuous flow chemists. If your product is susceptible to crashing out of solution, this can happen inside the reactor and blockages can occur. Clearing a blockage isn’t particularly difficult but can be annoying so is best avoided. Increasing concentration is something that can be done during optimization, and it is better to start too low than too high.
Avoid running using the most extreme parameters immediately
Now you have an exciting new set-up available, for the most eager users out there it is tempting to test the maximum performance of your system straight away.
You may come out with less than ideal results, but it is good to become comfortable with the processes that occur and ensure that reactions are safe. (Although, I have yet to meet anyone running at 250 °C and 20 bar who wasn’t a little bit cautious regardless of experience).
6. Change your experiments to help optimize your reaction
Have you finished your initial experiments and noticed the yield of your product is not as high as you would like?
Now begins the optimization stage: concentrations, temperatures, pressures, residence times, and many more variables can be adjusted. All parameters will have an effect, so based on the initial chemistry and your system’s capabilities you can decide which are the best to change. Many flow chemists choose to change one parameter at a time to analyze the effect of each.
Using Design of Experiment (DoE) software allows you to create a matrix of experiments which can alter specific parameters automatically and allow easier observation into the effect of each change.
7. Develop experience, gain confidence (and maybe even get published!)
From the initial stages, you’ll quickly gain experience and confidence in:
- Setting up flow experiments
- Expected results versus the actual results
- Optimizing experiments to help achieve their aims
With time and experience comes confidence, and with confidence comes great chemistry (and with great chemistry comes the chance to be published!).
Speak to Syrris about your chemistry
We’ve been helping chemists to implement continuous flow chemistry into their labs since 2001. If you’re considering implementing continuous flow techniques into your lab, or even if you’re already working in flow but looking to improve your results, simply fill in the contact form and an expert will get back to you.
About Neal Munyebvu (MChem)
As a Flow Chemistry Technical Specialist for the Syrris Support Team, Neal is responsible for installing Asia Flow Chemistry Systems in client sites around the world, helping chemists overcome issues, and enabling chemists to get the most out of their flow chemistry equipment.
Over the past 5 years or so the development of continuous flow electrochemical cells has made selective syntheses with high reactant-to-product conversions possible. These devices offer an easy access to electrochemical techniques which is driving its current re-assessment as a viable, attractive synthetic method. Discover more in this blog post.
My first introduction to practical flow chemistry was as a Research Chemist at Pfizer and my first thought was: “why on earth would I want to conduct my chemistry in tiny tubes?” A few years later I was the biggest advocate for it. This blog post explains why…
Let’s start with the basics and explain what flow chemistry actually is and talk a bit about why it’s so useful. Flow chemistry is the process of performing chemical reactions in a tube or pipe. Read on to learn more…
So why should your lab consider performing your chemistry using continuous flow chemistry techniques? Discover several reasons including faster and reactions, and accessing novel chemistries not possible in batch